Ever wondered about the difference between a macchiato and an americano when staring at the coffee shop menu? These two popular espresso-based drinks often cause confusion among coffee enthusiasts and casual drinkers alike.
While both drinks start with espresso, they diverge significantly in preparation, flavor profile, and strength. The macchiato offers a concentrated espresso experience with just a “stain” of milk, while the americano dilutes espresso with hot water for a milder, more voluminous drink. Understanding these key differences will help you order with confidence and discover which best suits your coffee preferences.
What Are Macchiatos and Americanos?
Macchiatos and americanos represent two distinct approaches to espresso-based coffee drinks, each with its own preparation method and flavor profile. Understanding their origins and traditional preparations helps appreciate why these beverages remain popular choices in coffee shops worldwide.
The Origins of Macchiato
The macchiato originated in Italy as a solution for baristas who needed to distinguish between regular espresso and those with a dash of milk. “Macchiato” literally translates to “stained” or “spotted” in Italian, referring to how the espresso is marked with a small amount of milk. Traditional Italian macchiatos contain just a dollop of steamed milk atop a shot of espresso, creating a strong coffee experience with minimal dairy influence. Coffee shops throughout Italy began serving this drink in the 1980s as customers sought espresso with just a touch of creaminess. The ratio typically follows 90% espresso to 10% milk, preserving the coffee’s intensity while slightly tempering its bitter edge.
The History of Americano
The americano emerged during Industry War II when American soldiers stationed in Italy found traditional espresso too intense for their taste preferences. These soldiers would add hot water to their espresso to create a drink reminiscent of the drip coffee they enjoyed back home. Baristas in Italy noticed this trend and began offering the diluted version as “caffè americano” (American coffee). The standard preparation involves pouring hot water over one or two shots of espresso, creating a coffee with the flavor complexity of espresso but the volume and reduced intensity of drip coffee. Many coffee enthusiasts appreciate how an americano maintains the nuanced flavor notes of espresso while offering a more extended drinking experience due to its larger volume.
The Fundamental Differences Between Macchiato and Americano
Macchiatos and americanos represent two distinct approaches to espresso-based beverages, each with its own unique character and preparation method. These popular coffee drinks share espresso as their foundation but diverge significantly in composition, taste profile, and brewing techniques.
Composition and Ingredients
Macchiatos consist primarily of espresso “marked” with a small amount of milk. A traditional macchiato contains a single or double shot of espresso topped with just a dollop of milk foam or a splash of steamed milk, maintaining a ratio of approximately 90% espresso to 10% milk. This minimal milk addition creates a strong coffee experience with just a hint of creaminess to soften the espresso’s intensity.
Americanos feature a simpler composition of just espresso and hot water. Unlike macchiatos, americanos contain no milk whatsoever, typically combining espresso and hot water in a 1:1 ratio. The addition of water dilutes the espresso’s concentration, resulting in a coffee that maintains the flavor characteristics of espresso but with reduced intensity and bitterness.
Brewing Methods
Macchiatos begin with pulling a fresh espresso shot as the foundation. Baristas then “mark” the espresso with a small amount of foamed or steamed milk, carefully adding just enough to create a distinct layer without fully integrating into the espresso. Several variations exist, including iced macchiatos for hot days, flat whites (which incorporate more milk), and latte macchiatos where the espresso is poured into the milk rather than the reverse.
Americanos follow a different preparation process focused on dilution rather than addition. First, a barista pulls a shot or double shot of espresso into a cup. Hot water is then added to the espresso, creating a larger volume beverage while preserving the essential flavor notes of the espresso. This method produces a smooth, less concentrated coffee that retains the nuanced flavors of espresso without its full-bodied intensity or thick mouthfeel.
Flavor and Aroma
Macchiatos deliver a bold, intense coffee experience with subtle sweetness from the milk component. The small amount of milk foam provides just enough creaminess to take the edge off the espresso’s natural bitterness without masking its complex flavor profile. Aromatically, macchiatos present a softer scent compared to pure espresso, as the milk slightly tempers the coffee’s natural fragrance.
Americanos offer a robust coffee flavor that’s more approachable than straight espresso. The hot water opens up the espresso’s flavor compounds, often revealing subtle notes that might be overwhelmed in concentrated form. Americanos produce a pronounced, aromatic coffee scent that fills the room, maintaining the distinctive espresso character but in a smoother, more diluted form that many coffee drinkers find more accessible for everyday consumption.
| Characteristic | Macchiato | Americano |
|---|---|---|
| Base ingredient | Espresso | Espresso |
| Secondary ingredient | Small amount of milk foam | Hot water |
| Milk content | 10% (foam or steamed) | None |
| Brewing approach | Espresso “marked” with milk | Espresso diluted with water |
| Flavor profile | Intense with slight creaminess | Bold but smoother than espresso |
| Aroma | Mild, slightly softened by milk | Strong, espresso-forward |
| Strength | Concentrated, strong | Milder, more diluted |
Flavor Profiles Compared
The true distinction between macchiatos and americanos lies in their unique flavor profiles and sensory experiences. These espresso-based beverages offer completely different taste sensations even though sharing the same foundation.
Macchiato’s Distinctive Taste
Macchiatos deliver an intense, concentrated coffee experience with espresso “stained” by a small dollop of steamed milk or milk foam. This minimal milk addition softens the pure espresso flavor slightly while maintaining the coffee’s bold character. The texture is noticeably dense and syrupy, creating a rich mouthfeel that coffee enthusiasts appreciate. Macchiatos typically come served in small espresso cups (about 1.3 to 2 oz), concentrating both flavor and caffeine content in each sip. Their aroma tends to be milder and sweeter than americanos due to the steamed milk component, offering a gentle complexity that balances the espresso’s intensity.
Americano’s Balanced Profile
Americanos present a more approachable coffee experience through the marriage of espresso and hot water. This combination, typically mixed in a 1:1 or 1:2 ratio, creates a larger volume beverage (about 3 oz or more) with a mellower taste that retains the espresso’s character. The dilution transforms the concentrated espresso into a smoother, more fluid drink while preserving the rich underlying coffee notes. Americanos feature a more pronounced aroma than macchiatos because they contain proportionally more espresso without milk to temper the scent. The flavor remains straightforward with moderate acidity and smooth bitterness, making it an excellent choice for those who enjoy espresso’s depth without its full intensity.
| Feature | Macchiato | Americano |
|---|---|---|
| Espresso Content | Single or double shot | Single or double shot |
| Milk Content | Small dollop of steamed milk or foam | None |
| Volume | Small (1.3 to 2 oz) | Larger (about 3 oz or more) |
| Flavor | Strong, rich, intense, creamy hint | Mellow, bold, slightly bitter |
| Texture | Dense, syrupy | Smooth, fluid |
| Aroma | Milder, sweeter | Stronger, more pronounced |
| Acidity | Moderate | Moderate |
| Serving | Espresso cup | Coffee cup |
| Calorie Count | ~20 calories (due to milk) | ~2 calories |
Caffeine Content and Strength
Both macchiatos and americanos deliver important caffeine content, though their delivery methods and perceived strength differ noticeably. Understanding these differences helps you choose the right espresso-based drink for your caffeine needs.
Caffeine Content
Macchiatos pack a concentrated caffeine punch with minimal dilution. At Dunkin’, a small macchiato contains approximately 237 mg of caffeine, while medium and large sizes offer 284 mg and 371 mg respectively. These high levels result from the typical two shots of espresso in even the smallest size. Starbucks macchiatos contain considerably less caffeine—around 75 mg in an 8 oz cup and up to 225 mg in a 20 oz cup—due to their higher milk content and added syrups.
Americanos provide remarkably similar caffeine content when compared size-for-size at major chains. Dunkin’s small americano contains 237 mg of caffeine, identical to their macchiato counterpart, with medium and large sizes matching at 284 mg and 371 mg respectively. The consistent caffeine levels reflect that both drinks typically start with the same espresso base.
Which Packs More Punch?
The caffeine content remains nearly identical between these drinks when ordered in the same size, particularly at Dunkin’ where both contain two espresso shots in a small serving. Their perceived strength, but, creates distinctly different experiences for coffee drinkers.
Macchiatos deliver their caffeine in a more concentrated form with just a dash of milk, creating an immediate and intense effect. Many coffee enthusiasts appreciate this direct approach, noting that the caffeine seems to hit faster when consumed in the macchiato’s compact form.
Americanos spread the same caffeine dose across more liquid, resulting in a less intense but longer-lasting experience. The water dilution creates a milder taste profile while maintaining the full caffeine content of the espresso shots. Regular americano drinkers often report enjoying a more gradual caffeine release.
Starbucks’ interpretation of macchiatos includes significantly more milk and flavored syrups than traditional versions, which explains their lower caffeine content compared to Dunkin’s offerings. Their americanos, but, maintain the expected caffeine levels since they’re diluted only with water rather than milk.
| Drink | Typical Caffeine (Small) | Preparation Style | Caffeine Experience |
|---|---|---|---|
| Macchiato | 237 mg (Dunkin’) / 75 mg (Starbucks) | Espresso with a small amount of milk | Concentrated, rapid caffeine effect |
| Americano | 237 mg (Dunkin’) | Espresso diluted with hot water | Same caffeine strength with milder taste |
The difference between these drinks isn’t about caffeine quantity but rather how that caffeine presents itself through concentration, dilution, and accompanying ingredients.
How to Order Like a Coffee Expert
Ordering specialty coffee drinks with confidence elevates your café experience. Understanding the exact terminology and preparation methods for macchiatos and americanos helps you communicate exactly what you want to baristas.
Macchiato Variations to Try
Macchiatos come in several distinct variations, each offering a unique espresso experience. The classic espresso macchiato features a shot of espresso “stained” with just a dollop of milk foam, delivering a bold, strong flavor profile while maintaining the espresso’s intensity. For those preferring a more milk-forward option, the latte macchiato reverses the traditional approach by filling a glass with steamed milk first, then marking it with espresso, creating a layered, creamier drink with a gentler coffee impact. Caramel macchiatos offer a sweetened experience, combining vanilla syrup with espresso and milk, finished with a caramel drizzle—though coffee purists might note this is more of a café creation than a traditional Italian preparation.
Americano Customization Options
Americanos provide extensive customization possibilities to suit your flavor preferences and mood. The iced americano transforms the traditional hot drink into a refreshing option by pouring espresso over cold water and ice, often resulting in a less bitter taste profile. Lungo variations use more water during the extraction process rather than after, creating a stronger yet smoother flavor compared to standard americanos. For a creamier texture and slightly sweeter profile, try ordering a caffè crema, which incorporates more hot water for a distinctive mouthfeel. Coffee enthusiasts seeking an extra caffeine boost might enjoy a red-eye—an americano that substitutes hot water with drip coffee, delivering maximum caffeine with reduced bitterness.
Best Food Pairings
Coffee and food pairings elevate your coffee experience by complementing flavors and creating balanced taste combinations. The distinct profiles of macchiatos and americanos pair naturally with different foods, improving both the coffee and your meal.
What to Eat with Your Macchiato
Macchiatos’ concentrated, bold flavor profile creates perfect harmony with light pastries that won’t overwhelm its intense taste. Crisp biscotti and buttery croissants stand out as ideal companions, offering contrasting textures while complementing the robust espresso notes. Sweet treats featuring caramel or almond flavors particularly enhance caramel macchiatos, creating a delightful flavor synergy that many coffee enthusiasts appreciate.
Small breakfast sandwiches or bite-sized savory options match a macchiato’s quick consumption style perfectly. The concentrated nature of this espresso drink pairs wonderfully with foods you can enjoy in just a few bites, mirroring the macchiato’s own compact serving size. Many coffee shops recognize this natural pairing, often displaying these complementary items near their espresso bar.
Ideal Companions for Americano
Americanos pair exceptionally well with traditional breakfast foods thanks to their milder flavor profile and larger serving size. Eggs, bacon, and toast create a balanced morning experience alongside an americano’s smooth, aromatic qualities. The drink’s approachable nature makes it versatile enough to accompany a full breakfast without overpowering any flavors.
Heartier, savory dishes find their match in americanos, with breakfast burritos and smoked salmon bagels complementing the coffee’s fuller body and pronounced aroma. The americano’s smooth yet distinctive espresso taste cuts through rich foods while providing a refreshing contrast. Sweet options like chocolate pastries or cinnamon rolls also enhance the americano experience, playing off its balanced flavor profile.
| Food Category | Macchiato Pairings | Americano Pairings |
|---|---|---|
| Pastries | Biscotti, croissants | Cinnamon rolls, chocolate pastries |
| Savory Items | Small sandwiches, quick bites | Breakfast burritos, smoked salmon bagels |
| Breakfast Foods | Light breakfast items | Eggs, bacon, toast, full breakfast plates |
| Sweet Treats | Caramel and almond desserts | Chocolate items, fruit-based pastries |
Making Them at Home
Brewing these espresso-based classics at home isn’t complicated once you understand the fundamental techniques and have the right tools. Both macchiatos and americanos start with quality espresso but diverge significantly in their preparation methods.
Essential Equipment for Each Drink
For Americanos, your equipment needs are relatively straightforward. An espresso machine or stovetop moka pot serves as the foundation for extracting rich espresso shots. Many home baristas find that even entry-level espresso machines produce satisfactory results for americanos. You’ll also need a kettle or reliable hot water source to dilute the espresso properly. The ratio typically falls between 1:1 and 1:3 espresso to water, depending on your preference for strength.
For Macchiatos, the equipment requirements become slightly more demanding. Besides an espresso machine capable of pulling consistent shots, you’ll need a milk frother or steaming wand to create the perfect microfoam. Small espresso cups or demitasse cups are essential for serving macchiatos properly, as they’re designed to hold the concentrated beverage while showcasing the distinct layers. Some home baristas invest in specialized macchiato glasses that highlight the contrast between the espresso and milk components.
The quality of your grinder significantly impacts both drinks. Espresso requires a fine, consistent grind that only burr grinders can reliably produce. Temperature-controlled kettles offer precision when adding water to americanos, ensuring you don’t scorch the espresso with water that’s too hot.
| Equipment Needs | Macchiato | Americano |
|---|---|---|
| Espresso machine | Required | Required |
| Milk frother/steamer | Required | Not needed |
| Specialized cups | Small espresso cups | Larger mug or cup |
| Grinder type | Burr grinder | Burr grinder |
| Additional tools | Thermometer for milk | Temperature-controlled kettle |
Creating the perfect macchiato demands attention to milk temperature and texture, while americanos require precision in water volume and temperature. Both drinks reward experimentation with different beans, roast levels, and preparation techniques until you find your perfect balance.
Which Coffee Is Right for You?
Your coffee preference typically depends on your taste for strength, flavor, and milk content. Americanos offer a milder, longer coffee experience without milk, making them ideal if you’re new to espresso or prefer a less intense caffeine hit. The hot water dilution creates a smooth, approachable drink that maintains essential coffee notes while reducing the intensity found in straight espresso.
Macchiatos deliver a bold, concentrated coffee experience with just a hint of creaminess. They’re perfect if you appreciate strong espresso flavors but enjoy a touch of milk to soften the intensity. The small amount of milk foam or steamed milk adds subtle sweetness without overwhelming the robust espresso character.
Consider these factors when choosing between these classic drinks:
- Flavor intensity: Americanos provide a more balanced taste, while macchiatos deliver concentrated coffee power
- Milk preference: Choose americanos for dairy-free options or macchiatos for a slight creaminess
- Drinking experience: Americanos offer a longer, more relaxed experience in a larger cup, while macchiatos provide an intense, quick coffee moment
- Caffeine delivery: Both contain similar caffeine amounts, but macchiatos deliver it in a more concentrated form
- Time of day: Americanos work well throughout the day, while macchiatos make excellent morning or after-meal options
Your ideal choice eventually comes down to personal preference – whether you value the clean, straightforward profile of an americano or the bold intensity with a gentle milk softening of a macchiato.
Conclusion
Whether you’re team macchiato or team americano the beauty of coffee lies in its diversity. Both drinks showcase espresso in distinctly different ways that cater to various preferences and occasions.
Macchiatos offer that bold concentrated experience with just a hint of milk to soften the edges. They’re perfect when you want that intense coffee flavor in a small powerful package.
Americanos provide a more approachable yet authentic coffee experience with their diluted but flavorful profile. They’re ideal for savoring over a longer period while still enjoying genuine espresso character.
Armed with this knowledge you can now confidently order or create these classic drinks at home. Remember that the best coffee is eventually the one that brings you joy with each sip.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between a macchiato and an americano?
The main difference lies in preparation and composition. A macchiato is espresso “marked” with a small amount of milk (typically 90% espresso, 10% milk), creating a strong, concentrated flavor. An americano is espresso diluted with hot water, resulting in a milder, larger beverage that resembles drip coffee in volume but maintains espresso’s distinctive flavor profile.
Which has more caffeine, a macchiato or an americano?
Both drinks contain the same amount of caffeine when made with the same number of espresso shots. A small macchiato from Dunkin’ contains approximately 237 mg of caffeine. However, the caffeine experience differs – macchiatos deliver caffeine in a concentrated form for an immediate effect, while americanos spread the same caffeine over a larger volume for a more gradual impact.
How did the americano get its name?
The americano originated during World War II when American soldiers stationed in Italy found traditional espresso too strong for their taste. They diluted the espresso with hot water to create a drink similar to the drip coffee they were accustomed to back home. The Italians called this creation “americano” (meaning “American-style”) because of its popularity with American servicemen.
What’s the proper way to drink a macchiato?
A traditional macchiato should be consumed quickly while it’s hot. Since it’s served in a small espresso cup, it’s meant to be enjoyed as a short, intense coffee experience. Drink it without stirring to experience the layering of flavors – the milk-marked top followed by the rich espresso underneath.
Can I order an iced americano or macchiato?
Yes, both drinks can be ordered iced. An iced americano is a popular variation where espresso is poured over cold water and ice. Iced macchiatos are also available, particularly in coffee chains like Starbucks, where the caramel macchiato has become a signature iced beverage with espresso poured over milk and finished with caramel drizzle.
What foods pair well with macchiatos and americanos?
Macchiatos pair excellently with light pastries like biscotti, croissants, or small breakfast sandwiches due to their intense flavor. Americanos complement a wider range of foods, including traditional breakfast items like eggs and toast, heartier dishes like breakfast burritos, and even chocolate desserts, thanks to their milder, more versatile flavor profile.
How can I make an americano at home?
To make an americano at home, you need an espresso machine or stovetop moka pot and a kettle. Pull 1-2 shots of espresso (1-2 oz), then add 3-6 oz of hot water, adjusting to your preferred strength. The typical ratio is 1:2 or 1:3 (espresso to water). Use freshly ground coffee beans for the best flavor and serve immediately.
Which drink should I choose if I don’t like strong coffee?
An americano would be the better choice if you don’t enjoy strong coffee. It provides the distinct flavor notes of espresso but in a milder, more approachable form due to the dilution with water. If you prefer some milk in your coffee but still want something less intense than a macchiato, consider ordering a café latte or a cappuccino instead.
What is a latte macchiato and how is it different from an espresso macchiato?
A latte macchiato is essentially the reverse of an espresso macchiato. While an espresso macchiato is espresso “marked” with a small amount of milk foam, a latte macchiato is steamed milk “marked” with espresso. It’s served in a tall glass with distinct layers: milk at the bottom, then espresso, topped with milk foam, creating a much milkier beverage than the traditional espresso macchiato.
Is a Starbucks macchiato the same as a traditional Italian macchiato?
No, they differ significantly. A traditional Italian macchiato is simply espresso with a small “mark” of milk foam (about 1-2 teaspoons). Starbucks’ most popular macchiato, the caramel macchiato, is a much sweeter, larger drink with vanilla syrup, steamed milk, espresso, and caramel drizzle. It’s closer to a flavored latte than to the traditional espresso macchiato served in Italy.
About The Author
